Current Issue

Vol. 33, number 1

editorial

To the Readers of Transforming Anthropology

Christen A. Smith and Ryan Cecil Jobson


 

This article traces Black environmental relations in the stewardship of community gardens and other green spaces in the city of Newark, New Jersey. It engages with a widely held belief that Black diasporic people, particularly those who live in cities, are alienated from nature or altogether opposed to agriculture as a result of the historical traumas of slavery and its immediate afterlives, including sharecropping and convict leasing. Focused on Black Newarkers with marked roots in the American South and the Caribbean, this essay follows gardeners and other stewards of urban green space as they contend with the legacy of the plantation yet still frame land cultivation and stewardship as a mode of recovery and resistance. It highlights the ways in which Black growers and other green space stewards indeed reckoned with their associations between cultivation and captivity but did so in ways that enabled them to name present-day labor extractions and enact alternative forms of care and self-determination.

 

White supremacist ideas are prefabricated within the concept of a hierarchized white racial order and resultant unequal distribution of life and death. These age-of-Enlightenment-humanist ideas remain tethered to public opinion and policy, cohering racial whiteness as the ideal in a collective political unconscious. Of course, an anthropology of white supremacy is not a departure from existing radical political economic analytics but rather a companion/continuation of related projects. In this essay, we provide analytical terms specific to the anthropology of white supremacy and suggest five principles, theorized through the context of ethnographic encounters in, and historiography of, the city of Detroit. More broadly, this article suggests that white supremacy is a crucial foundational element toward the emergence of capitalism and liberalism in the modern period. To follow, we take a specific if narrowed approach attuned to the way that the concept, white supremacy, a priori marks the structural signification of persistent, destructive ideas such as scientific racism and racial whiteness as the unraced, nonwhite lack of reason/understanding and nonwhite lack of being-in-the-world—ideas that anthropology as a discipline would do well to unpack.


 

This paper considers the relationship between gendered care work and state-sponsored disaster recovery in New York City. As an ethnographer and a volunteer at New York Relief Center (NYRC), which provided disaster case management to Puerto Ricans displaced by Hurricane María, I demonstrate how despite state funding, Puerto Ricans displaced following Hurricane María (2017) remained unhoused, unemployed, and disconnected from services. In what amounts to an ambivalent form of state care, city bureaucracies not only permitted this but also, to a significant degree, produced disaster migrants’ deepening precarity. Disaster case managers (DCMs)—the first point of contact—engaged in gendered radical care to create alternative forms of recovery. DCMs, all working-class Latinas, mobilized personal networks and invested countless unpaid hours to secure services and materials given a low priority by NYRC. DCMs demonstrate how precarity gives way to life-affirming practices such as community activism, the formation of networks of care, and in some cases the crafting of new possibilities for sociality and solidarity. These efforts interrupt the everyday slow violence that diasporic and displaced Puerto Ricans encounter because of ecological injustice, state ambivalence, and coloniality.

 

In Batey Liberty, a sugarcane settlement located in the northwest region of the Dominican Republic, community conversations about witches abound. The witch is perceived as a corporeal and ephemeral figure that transcends dimensions of time and space. Residents of Batey Libertad differently articulate their relationship to varied iterations of the witch, which in turn inform their everyday lives. This article interrogates what I call “witch talk” to draw attention to the correlation between disclosures of witch encounters and specific occurrences of state violence through the act of immigration raids. It argues that the discourse surrounding the witch is a trauma response to the ongoing and increasing persecution of people of Haitian descent in the Dominican Republic. An analysis of witch talk reveals that the witch is a proxy for the unnamed state. However, a reorientated examination of the witch offers decolonial possibilities for what her presence could signify.

A Quare Analysis of Coming Out in Frank Ocean’s and Tyler, the Creator’s Discographies

Jeff Gu

Tyler, the Creator has enjoyed nearly unrivaled buzz in the alternative hip-hop scene since the early 2010s. His eccentric music shook audiences worldwide with themes of murder, arson, and rape, so, unsurprisingly, controversy never strayed far. However, Tyler’s fourth studio album, Flower Boy (2017), presented a never-before-seen emotional tenderness, in which he comes out as having had romantic relationships with men. Despite his brave honesty, listeners reacted with doubt more than anything, as they have learned not to take what he says seriously. The contrast becomes stark when comparing Tyler’s coming-out to that of R&B artist Frank Ocean, a close friend and collaborator. In 2012, Frank revealed in a Tumblr post that his first love was with a man, which was met with praise from fans and celebrities alike. This reception of another queer Black male musician of comparable popularity shows how radically distinct the public reception of Tyler’s coming-out truly was. However, the question begs, why did everybody openly accept Frank Ocean as bisexual while finding it difficult to believe Tyler, the Creator when he came out as queer?

 


HOW TO ACCESS THE JOURNAL

Association of Black Anthropologists and American Anthropological Association members
All members of the Association of Black Anthropologists (ABA) and the American Anthropological Association (AAA) receive access to Transforming Anthropology as a benefit of membership. All journal content is available on the University of Chicago Press site, and your member access through the AAA website is now in effect. To read the journal, log in to your AAA account and follow the link to the journal homepage.

Print subscriptions can be added to your ABA membership through the University of Chicago Press. To purchase a print subscription, visit the Transforming Anthropology subscription page and select "ABA Members" from the "Subscribe" drop-down menu.

Individual subscribers (non-members)
Individual subscribers will access the journal through the University of Chicago Press website.